Sometimes, it can help ground you just to write the thoughts down. This passage, for instance looks a lot like the inside of my brain when I spiral. My spirals are exclusively part of my OCD. This type of dissonant thought symphony is always a signal that it’s time for me to slow down and take things one step at a time. Start on the outside when there’s an outside trigger. In this case, your trigger is taking a break from a relationship.
Look at your relationship like an open door. “Taking time off” “taking a break” or “breaking up” are all acts of closing that door.
Distinguishing whether loyalty was necessary when that door is closed for it to open again was up to your partner’s discretion, since I assume he was the one to close it. Your very detailed thought process makes me think that the lines drawn would be much clearer if you’d been the one to close it, but correct me if I’m wrong.
Now we tackle the inner conflict. In this case, your thoughts vs your self-image and how your belief in God plays a part.
Let me tell you, I struggled a lot with belief in God, and while I don’t believe anymore, I generally retain a sense that everything happens for a reason. But not the things in my head; those are all mine, be they welcome guests or proverbial demons I fight against. My struggle was always reconciling the turmoil I experienced daily with being observed and condoned by a loving and merciful God. My OCD found my faith and took that away. If I ever find my way back, God’s door is open. No person is so forgiving. No human is so prepared to open themself to potential abandonment time and again.
From my life experiences, if there is a God, he sends people, not thoughts. If God ever did anything for me, it was putting my future spouse in my path when I’d resolved to live my life recklessly and dangerously, it was sending me my first child when I was at my lowest point in life. But I like to think I chose those paths for myself. If God was involved, it was only in giving me the option. I was making my own signs, and the people I love lifted me up out of the dark.
And while we’re on the topic of the big guy in the sky, he will not judge you on your passing thoughts, but your actions and choices. Your fidelity to a partner manifests in your real world impact, not in your head. It’s why moral values exist. To be weighed in your head and influence your choices. The blessing and responsibility of free will.
For instance, the impact your partner’s unclear boundaries are having on you. Maybe he couldn’t anticipate your distress. Despite intentions, if you’re on a break and fidelity is in question from either side of the door, there needs to be room for communication. You can’t guess someone else’s boundaries and live by them when they aren’t even around.
So to pull the uncertainty out by the root, you can try to open the door and reach out, or you can decide that you have mutually closed the door, and while it is closed your actions and desires have no bearing on whether or not that door opens again.
Then you can tackle figuring out whether your feelings for your friend are real.
You’re trying to fix everything all at once and taking all the responsibility for the confusion on yourself and your disorder. I do this all the time. It gives me the illusion of control. If it’s all on me, I can fix it. If it’s all on me, I can stop it from happening again.
Relationships, breaks and break ups are confusing. Needing clarification or clear communication is not the same as asking for reassurance. I know that this statement is reassurance in and of itself, but it’s fact and I stand by it. It’s been one of my biggest hurdles and remains to this day.
Here is the bottom line: no clear boundaries have been communicated to you. You are hesitant to reach out because you’re on a break.
At the end of the day, what happens when the door is closed doesn’t matter. It will always open again if that’s what you both want. Not because God wills it. God gave that will to you.
Reach out, or leave it up to future you to deal with. God gave you the tools. Leaving it up to God is for things you or others can’t control, and if your partner wants that door to open again in the future, he has a responsibility to communicate that to you, and account for your boundaries as well as establishing his own.