@doss626 - Hi there,
I've been meaning to write back to you for a while now, but college and my mind have gotten the best of me this month! I'm finally beginning to feel some peace and it might be helpful to some people if I shared...
At the start of this semester, my senior year of college, I found out my first love had broken up with the girl he'd most recently dated (this is the first love I referenced in my initial post, whom I've dated on and off for most of college but ended it when my mental health started suffering). At the same time, I let him back into my life to support him through some personal things he was going through - I was mentally better and I had been pining over him the whole summer. We have since hooked up a few times, and admitted we both still had feelings for each other, but were both obviously confused.
I found out a couple of days ago that he and his hometown friend discovered they had mutual feelings for each other over the Thanksgiving holiday. To protect my little heart, I sat with him yesterday on a bench during a rainy Georgia afternoon and told him I didn't want to remain in contact with him anymore as it would be painful. I had thought ad nauseam about what I wanted to say to him before meeting with him. Do I lay everything out there and try to get him back? Was this my only chance to do so? Do I choose to not mention anything about the connection between him and I and just wish him well?
Recently, through some self-investigation, I've slowly begun to uncover the nature of that gut-feeling I had mentioned before. It came partly through conversations with people close to me, through reconsiderations of particular things he'd said in the past that had stuck with me, through interactions with my OWN lifelong hometown crush over Thanksgiving break, through my friend offering me her umbrella to walk to class yesterday morning. Your reply to me! How funny and beautiful is that.
I decided on what felt right and most freeing in the moment: I told him how I considered laying myself all out in front of him in that moment, letting him know how much I loved and cared about him. I told him why I chose not to, what that gut feeling was that was holding me back, what I wished I'd asked for during the relationship, and why I felt like I shouldn't have had to ask for those things.
I can't lie and say that I didn't wish he would've turned to me on that bench yesterday after I explained everything and confessed his undying love for me. However, there is the other side to that coin, and there is a reason why I hadn't done so first. I wished him everything beautiful and good, and we parted ways.
All that being said, thank you so much for your reply to me. Your decision to do so and share some of your insight gave me hope for my future self, and I needed it to make some decisions not based in fear. I hope your day and your life moving forward bring you everything good; YOU deserve that, friend!
- Emma