I feel terrible and guilty writing this. I find my boyfriend’s best friend really physically attractive, maybe more attractive than my boyfriend. It’s giving me a serious case of “the grass is greener elsewhere” feelings. I find my boyfriend more emotionally attractive though. There’s a lot of “icks” with the other guy but I can’t get past his good looks. My boyfriend and I have similar values and he’d be a great life partner. The other guy, I’m pretty sure, would be emotionally unavailable in a relationship as he’s not looking for anything serious which feels familiar to me as in the past I only fell in love with emotionally unavailable men. My boyfriend isn’t the most conventionally attractive guy, he’s average but sometimes I think he’s really attractive and he does turn me on. I’ve experienced ROCD thoughts since the beginning (am I in love, do I find him attractive enough?). Last weekend was amazing, we’d spent two weeks not seeing each other because we were both away and coming back together felt like the honeymoon phase again. I was so in love and told him I loved him whilst looking him in the eyes and I didn’t doubt my feelings at all. We talked about getting engaged and I was whole heartedly in it. His best friend has become another focus of my anxious thoughts but there’s some truth behind it which makes me more worried and more convinced I shouldn’t be in this relationship. It feels unfair on him but I want him to be my forever. Please don’t be harsh if you comment, it’s taken a lot to type this out and get it off my chest

It sounds like OCD is trying to play tricks on you and your current boyfriend's relationship. I don't think there's anything wrong with finding someone else good looking while in a relationship. Of course, if you're acting on that and taking it seriously, that's an issue, which doesn't sound like what you're doing. I think a person being attracted to someone is something they can't help. Everyone is wired differently. One person that may not be attractive to someone does it for another person. Another thing. You don't want to try and prove your feelings to your boyfriend as proof or confirmation of what OCD is saying. You know how OCD is: It's just gonna make you doubt regardless. Catch the thoughts that don't help you, label them, and move on. Continue being happy with your boyfriend. I hope this helps

I have a lot of thoughts on this sort of thing (monogamy is a very dear value of mine and cheating obsessions and fear of losing attraction to my gf are themes of mine). Here are my two cents: “Conventionally attractive” is not something you have to recognize. Attraction is subjective. Sometimes we like the “security” of conventionally attractive features, because it seems tried and true, because society tells us it is what’s real. It is a construct, meaning it is epistemologically objective, meaning you can identify just what makes someone conventionally attractive. But a construct also means it is ontologically subjective— it only exists if we recognize it. Instead of staying in that comfort zone of conditioning ourselves to like what is conventionally attractive, why not dive into the deep end— the definition of attractive that is authentic to you? Why can’t you decide your boyfriend is your definition of attractive — even physically? Since it’s subjective, who can say you’re wrong? Of course this involves some fear— what if I never overcome my conditioned desire for x feature? what if i never overcome my conditioned distaste for y feature? Even when you don’t actually find anyone else attractive, these fears can still show up. The tools we have to deal with OCD are well suited to deal with these fears too. One important step to this is addressing how we look at people other than our partner. We see someone and they get a response from our brain, but what do we do in response? Something that hurts my attraction to my gf is to savor the image, to try and trap it in my head, like a chipmunk storing acorns in its cheeks for later. Or the OCD response, which is to anxiously compare my gf to see if she “measures up” or if my response is as immediate. But the response that gives life to my relationship is to do nothing to appreciate or suppress it— just let it fly away, never keeping it for my private appreciation, never comparing it to my partner. Because we have chosen to make a sharp division between our partner and everyone else. We have designated them as the person to whom we are monogamously committed. As such, they are in a different category altogether. How can you compare apples and oranges? It is when we dilute our faculties to savor and to create exalting narratives by using these on others that we begin to place our partner on the same plane as everyone else, subject to arbitrary standards similar to those we use to shop for dead objects. It is a sacrifice. It may mean giving up things we might hold dear, like porn, celebrity crushes, prior sexual partners, etc. But imo what we lose in those fantasies of the unobtainable is more than made up for in the life we actually live. Hope this helps.

Yes of course you are sometimes going to find other people attractive EVEN when you are dating someone you love very much. It’s human nature. I’ve been struggling with something similar in my relationship. I’ll see someone attractive and go, oh no.. what if they are a better fit for me? Or I’ll have a good conversation with someone and think… oh no what if I would be more compatible with this person instead? The most helpful thing to do (in my experience) is to do the following: 1) realize these kinds of concerns/ obsession (i.e. worrying if finding someone attractive or fun to talk to etc. means you shouldn’t be with your partner) is an OCD thought, 2) ask yourself - do you know for 100% certain who your best partner is? (If the answer is no.. then there is no reason to try and solve something you don’t know because there is NO way to find this answer with 100% certainty). 3) have faith in your future self and know that you chose to commit to your partner today. The only thing you need to handle right now is what is in front of you. Your ocd/ fear is trying to get you to think that if you worry about these things now and ruminate/ analyze these concerns.. it will save you from your fear materializing. But really ocd makes things very unclear and not enjoyable. Try and return to the present with yourself and your partner :)

Thank you everyone for your really thought out and detailed responses, they’re really appreciated! I would never cheat on him, I love and respect him too much to do that to such a wonderful soul. I want to build a future with him so I will treat this like any OCD thought and take on some of the advice you’ve all given. Thank you so much again