- Date posted
- 12h
I recently realized that my favorite band, and one I've been a fan of for a while, has a lyric in an older song that can be insensitive to a marginalized community. The band is incredibly committed to making their work as inclusive as possible and the slight isn't very well known so I'm almost sure they were unaware, but still I was caught off guard. I researched in some online spaces and found some people in the community arguing for reaching out to a creator in a situation like this and some people against it, saying they don't mind. I've tried asking directly but haven't been able to post because these spaces don't want to be about having to explain what to do to those not affected, which I totally understand. However this has left me kind of stuck, and I concluded I should stop listening to the band. This has left me pretty sad to just give away something that has meant so much to me. I have no idea what I can do and it's left me feeling frustrated. At the same time I feel so selfish because I know I don't go through a fraction of what this community goes through, and I just want to listen to my little songs. I feel even worse knowing that while some of this comes from a genuine desire to make the world more inclusive, a part of it also has to come from a selfish desire to listen to the band. I try to make up for this by fighting for this community whenever I can, even when I have no stake, but I don't know if this justifies it. Sometimes I have the urge to listen to the band but just not that specific song. Every time I do I start to think in "What Ifs" like "What if interacting with them pushes them further into popularity and someone from this community finds them and is hurt by this lyric?" or "What if someone's harmful biases are reinforced by this lyric?" Which definitely seems like OCD thoughts. At the same time, they're very possible situations, and knowing what this community goes through, it doesn't seem like a risk worth taking. I've spoken with my therapist about it and she isn't sure either, calling it a very complicated situation. What sucks is that this band almost certainly wasn't being malicious, only ignorant. Still, this can cause harm, and I don't know what to do. Also, I don't want to place any blame whatsoever on the affected community. It's natural that there's not consensus, and society is often so ignorant that different people will have different ways of solving it. I am not even close to being the true victim in this situation nor do I have the credentials to say "Ah! This is what a person should do in this situation!" But I've been feeling really anxious and depressed and I don't know what to do. I'm more than willing to give up this band if it helps fight oppression, but at the same time it's so hard to do away with something that's meant a lot to me. Sorry for the lengthy post. Any advice?